Murder most foul! Or was it a bad-tempered mare?

Are you sitting comfortably? Then I’ll begin… here is today’s story (with links, of course, to the Lost Hamlets and the Downing and Whitehouse families!)

To begin at the beginning… it is spring of 1822. It has been a mild spring and the weather is good for hunting. You, Joseph Downing, are a wealthy and respected young man of 38, with a profession as a beast leech and a practice which you took over several years ago from your late uncle Isaac who was an eccentric old gentleman, from whom you inherited both money and several properties. You are married with one son and three daughters  and, after your uncle’s death, you  moved from Portway to Turner’s Hill.

Yours is a close-knit little circle. Your father Paul Downing also lives on Turner’s Hill, although his house there was the site of some disturbance last year when four local Rowley men broke in and stole various items and last September, at Stafford Assizes they were all sentenced to death for this, although the sentences were commuted and the four were all transported to Australia instead.

Your wife Nancy, who you married in 1810, has her parents and three older brothers  living nearby. One of those brothers, Samuel married your sister and only sibling Mary in 1813 so you four are double in-laws. Mary and Samuel live in West Bromwich but sadly have no children of their own so they have adopted your eldest daughter Emma and have paid for your children Matilda and Isaac to go to school.

You and Samuel are good friends and share a love of shooting so you often go shooting together in the Lightwoods area of Quinton, riding from your respective homes and meeting at the house of Thomas Fox, a blacksmith, in Beech Lane, on the turnpike road from Birmingham to Hales Owen. You bring your own victuals but buy in beer in generous quantities from the local pubs, which the three of you consume after your shooting. Life, it seems, is very good.

So, how does it happen that in September of that same year, you, Joseph Downing, find yourself on trial at Shrewsbury Assizes, in peril of your life – accused of the murder of your own brother-in-law Samuel Whitehouse in the woods on your way home after such a day out? Read on to find out!

The trial account

Summer Assizes – Shrewsbury, Saturday August 3 1822, Criminal Court (Halesowen was in Salop or Shropshire at this time so the case went to the Shrewsbury Assizes, not Stafford.)

As can be imagined, this case excited much interest and the newspapers of the time carried extensive reports, much of which I am showing verbatim:

“The trial of Joseph Downing for the murder of his brother-in-law came on at seven this morning, long before which hour every seat in the court was occupied. A large proportion of the audience were ladies. Mess’rs Puller, Campbell and Male appeared for the prosecution and Mess’rs Jervis, Pearson and Russell for the defence.

The indictment charged the prisoner with having, on the 3rd April last, given Samuel Whitehouse a mortal blow on the back part of the head with a gun barrel, of which he languished till the 5th April, when he died.

The prisoner, in a firm tone, pleaded – Not Guilty.”

This is the evidence which was put before the Court:

On the 3rd October Joseph Downing and his brother-in-law Samuel Whitehouse had met by arrangement at Tom Fox’s house and forge. Both came on horseback from their homes, about four miles apart, Samuel riding a mare which he had not had very long but which was described as ‘skittish’ and, while they were waiting for Joseph to arrive, he told Tom Fox that the mare had already thrown Samuel on a previous visit to Fox, having run against and broken down a stile for which he had had to compensate the farmer and of which he had said “what a mercy it was she had not killed him”. He said he would get rid of her, for she was so shy; he was afraid she would kill him some time or other.  The same mare had also subsequently thrown and kicked one of his grooms. Samuel also brought his spaniel, a gun dog bred to find, flush and retrieve game from undergrowth and water.

Joseph had not two but three purposes with his visit. He came to shoot and socialise but also brought a colt to be shod at the forge and a new gun barrel which he wanted Fox to bore out and widen in his forge. Downing’s mare and colt were left in Fox’s warehouse for the day, Whitehouse’s mare tied up at Fox’s ‘hovel’, as Fox described it himself during his evidence. Then he loaned Joseph a gun and the three men went out shooting. Fox also testified that “During the whole time, there were no words of anger between them; they were very friendly; I never saw them better friends in my life.”

Fox told the court that he had known Joseph and Samuel very well for several years. They were great friends and had been for years.  They were in the habit of coming frequently to his house for the purpose of going shooting together, putting up their horses, and sending for beer to the public houses. They usually brought their own victuals with them. On that day, they went out shooting together, and he accompanied them. They all returned about three in the afternoon, after being out between four and five hours.

This is Fox’s description of the rest of the evening:

“On our return we all took some refreshment. I then tried to widen the breech of the gun-barrel and we walked out to look at Whitehouse’s farm. We returned about six. We then took more refreshment, both food and drink. The ale came from the “Dog” public house, and was paid for by both. Altogether we had 12 quarts of ale. [A quart, a quarter of a gallon, is two pints, so the total here is twenty four pints of beer].  We three, a man of mine, my son and wife, partook of it; but they had not more than two quarts (four pints) of the whole. I, Whitehouse and Downing drank equal quantities [which would have been twenty pints, nearly seven pints each for the three men]. We continued drinking until nearly nine o’clock [so these quantities of ale were drunk over three hours]. In this time, Downing and I laid a wager on the age of Downing’s colt of £1. Each of us produced £1, and gave the money to Whitehouse to hold, who put it into one of his pockets, I did not see which.

 I looked at the clock just before Downing and Whitehouse went away, which was on the stroke of nine. It was moonlight, clear but cloudy at times. It was rather calmish. Whitehouse went first. I fetched his horse from my hovel, where it had been put up, and I helped him on. At that time we were all fresh [drunk!]; but the deceased could sit his horse, as well I saw. I held his horse, and gave him the gun. It was then in the state which it had been the whole day. The lock was then entire, and the spring in its place. Downing followed, and mounted his horse, which had been kept in our warehouse. He was in the same [drunken] state in which we were.

They crossed the turnpike road to go through the wood. There is a narrow path through the wood which joins the road near the gravel pit. Across this path there are two gates, one next the road, and another 35 yards further on. I opened the first gate for them; Whitehouse passed through first and Downing followed. I went to the second gate. Here Downing said he had forgotten his gun barrel, and asked Whitehouse to stop or he would lose his road, as he had done the time before. I went back for the gun barrel, walked at a moderate pace, and on my return found Downing waiting for me at the gate. Whitehouse had gone on. The trees shade the road, so that more than 100 yards cannot be seen; but he was out of sight. I delivered the gun barrel to Downing, who rode on at a foot’s pace, leading the colt in his right hand. The colt was about 2 years old. The path is what is called ‘a little trig road’.

I returned and went to bed.”

So, this evidence shows, the two men had, after a night of hard drinking, left Fox’s house to make their way home cross country, all three men, apparently, considerably the worse for drink!

Perhaps, by this time, you feel a map would be useful? When I first read the trial reports and tried to place the events in my mind, I certainly did. So here is an extract from the OS One-Inch map from 1872, somewhat later but I have put stars at Turner’s Hill, The Oaks at West Bromwich (which was  possibly where Samuel lived and this site was certainly associated with the Whitehouse family a few years later) and also at the probable site of Tom Fox’s forge, opposite the Light Woods.

Copyright: David and Charles, Newton Abbot, Devon.

And Joseph and Samuel had become separated in the wood. Presumably at some point their routes would have diverged anyway as one was going to Rowley, probably – looking at the map via Whiteheath Gate, and the other to West Bromwich, perhaps via Oldbury.

This extract from the Tithe Map for the area shows Plot Number 217, described in the apportionments as ‘house, blacksmith’s shop and garden, Plot 217, the property of Lord Lyttelton, at the Turnpike road’s (now Hagley Road West) eastern extremity in the township measured 2 roods, 1 pole.’ And the Fox family were associated with this site for most of the 19th century.

Copyright: Michael Hall

So this was right at the edge of the parish, on the toll-road, very near to the Beech Tree Inn, probably about where the road from Harborne comes up to meet the Hagley Road West and where eventually the Wolverhampton New Road began when it was built much later. This was also near Warley Woods and the Bear Wood, so there would have been some promising areas for shooting.

What happened next?

Now we hear the evidence of Richard Aston, an apprentice shoemaker:

“I am apprentice to John Bridge of the Beech Tree, who is a shoemaker. On the 3rd April I set out for Oldbury about seven o’clock. On my return I took the road from West Bromwich. I passed Parker’s house about 20 minutes after nine.  I heard a horse galloping; I stopped it; the bridle had been in our shop for mending, and I noticed the broadness of the reins. I took the horse to Ezekiel Dearns, and inquired who had passed that way. In consequence of what I there heard, I pursued the road towards Fox’s.

In my way, near Wood’s Gate I found a body. I saw a hat lying about two yards from the body, nearer to me. The body lay across the road. A gun was lying about two yards from the body, near to the hat. I dismounted and found it was Mr Whitehouse. He was leaning on his right side, his face towards Fox’s, and he lay in the road. He was not then sensible.

I led the horse to our house. I afterwards went to Mrs Fox’s and she and a man named Henley returned with me. As I was going back to the body, I heard a man halloo, as if he was making an alarm. I thought it might be Mr Whitehouse got up, hallooed “Mr Whitehouse,” and heard a horse gallop from the place where he lay. He was then lying on his back, the flap of his smallclothes unbuttoned and his waistcoat stripped under his arm; and his pockets, to the best of my recollection, unbuttoned. In the left-hand breeches pocket we found nothing; in the right-hand pocket two £1 notes; his watch was gone.

We took him to the Beech Tree public house. It was three quarters of an hour from the time I first saw him, till I saw him again. I took the gun the first time, and left it at Mr Bridge’s shop. The next morning I found that the spring was off and shot in it but no wadding.

About five in that morning, I saw Downing, and again between twelve and one. The second time he brought me the spring of the gun; there was a little dirt in the middle of it. He said a good many had been looking for it, but no-one could find it but he. I had told Hanley that the spring was missing. I went with the prisoner to the place where he found the spring which was a few yards from the spot where the deceased was found. The place was soft and dirty; there was dirt in the muzzle of the gun, so that it appeared to have fallen on the muzzle. Afterwards I saw Mr Granger riding a mare which I believe to be that which I caught.”

Cross-examined by Mr Pearson:

“The gun was in a ditch, where the gravel was sufficiently hard to throw it on one side. I caught the mare at a gate. She seemed alarmed but I did not see her tremble. The gate was little more than half a mile from the place where I found the deceased. When I reached the deceased, the mare started. A spaniel was lying by the body and he went with me. Whitehouse breathed hard, like a man who was intoxicated. I lifted him up, under the arms; and did not, the first time, perceive the waistcoat tucked up. The person of the deceased must have been removed between the first and second time I saw him. When I went to Fox’s, Mrs Fox called twice to waken her husband; I heard someone answer whom I thought was Mr Fox, as if drunk or asleep. The gun was placed in the shop, where many might have seen it.”

Poor Samuel Whitehouse! Knocked senseless and then robbed, it seemed.

Mrs Fox had gone back to alert her husband to what had happened. He said:

“I was awakened by my wife who told me that Whitehouse lay hurt at the Beech Tree. I went to the Beech tree public house and found him there wounded. I mounted Whitehouses’s mare and rode to Downings to inform him what had happened. It was nearly two in the morning before I reached Downings, in consequence of the badness of the road. I went by the same trig road. I called Downing, who came down, and I informed him of the state of his brother-in-law. I said he was very badly hurt, and had lost his money. Downing said “he was very sorry it had happened and could not think which way he went that he had missed of him. Then we made ready to come to the Beech Tree. It was nearly four before we started, because the mare had not been fed, and it was necessary to feed her. Downing mounted his horse. In returning to the Beech Tree we came through that wood. Before that time I had been told by my wife in what place Whitehouse had been found. When we reached it, we stopped and looked about to see it we could find anything. It was then day-break. He dismounted and looked about. He said he thought there was some blood but it was not light enough to see. I looked and thought it was blood, but it was scarcely light enough to see.

We then went on to the Beech Tree and arrived nearly at five. Downing went into the room where Whitehouse was. I followed him; he was then so sensible as to know me. Downing went to the bedside and asked him if he was sick. I think he said “Yes” but I did not hear him. He shook hands with me very much. About an hour afterwards, Downing made him some tea, fed him with a teaspoon, took his hand, and felt his pulse, which he said beat regularly. I did not see Whitehouse take Downing’s hand. He knew me, I am sure. 

We remained at the Beech Tree for nearly three hours. The Doctor and Downing consulted that Mr Baddeley, of Dudley, another Doctor, should be called in, and Downing went [to Dudley] for him. Between 10 and 11, Downing returned to the Beech tree.

 Before Mr Baddeley came, Downing and I went together to the trig road. We searched all about the place where Whitehouse had lain. We found horses in the road before we came to the spot, on that side of the gate where he was found. We then went to the place and Downing found the spring of Whitehouse’s gun in the rut which might be three or four inches deep, and had no water. We found nothing else. We then went back to the Beech Tree. I might be 3 yards from Downing when he found it. He said “Here is his gun-spring,” before he took it up.”

The gun barrel taken away by Downing was produced, and identified by the witness. The spring of the gun was also produced and sworn to be that found, and the gun of Whitehouse was identified in the same manner.

All of this evidence was presented for the prosecution, so they clearly felt it was sufficient to charge Joseph Downing. Downing’s barrister Mr Jervis cross-examined Tom Fox.  More facts (and opinions) emerged:

Tom Fox: “I do not remember any attempt of my wife to wake me because I was in liquor. The mare had been ridden to Hales Owen, about three miles, to fetch a doctor, after being caught a mile from my house. I was present while the surgeon searched the head. Whitehouse appeared to know me, as he shook hands with me very much by the right hand. Directions to fetch Downing were given in the presence of Whitehouse. Before this the doctor had said that he was in danger but might recover.

When I reached Downing’s, he appeared to have been in bed; he dressed and came to me. I told him “Whitehouse was badly hurt, and had lost his money.” He went and gave the mare a feed of hay; she had been 11 or 12 miles, besides having stood all day.

When we reached the Beech Tree, Downing went up first and I followed him. He went to the bedside and spoke to Whitehouse. He administers to cattle, and is somewhat acquainted with medicine. Whitehouse looked at him, and seemed to know him. When he shook hands with  me, I was nearer to his hand than Downing. When Downing felt his pulse, he seemed sensible and showed no aversion. There was a twitching of his limbs on the right side which made it difficult to keep the clothes on him. He took the tea from the prisoner’s hand. Mr Bloxam being gone, Downing desired that the doctor might be fetched, and both the Mess’rs Bloxam came. He remained until their arrival, and desired them to do the best they could for him. They examined and dressed the wound again in his presence, and he looked at it. The two brothers of the deceased came after the dressing. Downing then desired that Baddeley, his own surgeon might be fetched and Downing and Thomas Whitehouse went for him. Downing returned first.

Then we went to the spot and he plucked out the spring of the gun with a stick. He attended the coroner’s inquest at every sitting, and also attended the funeral.”

Then some evidence was called from local people about various movements:

Ezekiel Dearn examined by Mr Campbell:

“I am a nailer by business, living by the side of the road. In the morning of the 3rd April I saw the prisoner and deceased separately pass my house. About nine in the evening, as near as I could guess, I saw Downing return at a gentle trot leading a colt, at a rate of 4 or 5 miles an hour. A few minutes later, two strangers passed on foot in the same direction. They were walking at a common pace. About four or five minutes after, Mr Whitehouse’s mare came up loose at a gallop, and she passed on. Near four minutes after Aston brought the mare to my door.

Cross examined by Mr Russell: The mare continued to gallop as long as I saw her: 10 or 12 minutes elapsed after Downing passed before the mare came by. Afterwards I continued working at my nail shop about an hour, by the road side; but I saw no other man or horse pass. Downing could not have gone back without my seeing him.”

Thomas Wakeman, examined by Mr Puller:

“On the 3rd April I went to Oldbury, and returned by the Rowley Road. I set out to come home 20 minutes before nine. It is about two miles and a half from the place whence I set off to Parker’s. I came gently, walking all the way. About forty yards before I got to Parker’s, I met a man leading a horse which seemed a young one. I wished him “good night”. He was going at a good fair walk. At that time I did not know him. He did not appear to take any notice of me. He was like the prisoner at the bar. Before I met him, I heard a halloo which seemed to come from before me. Afterwards, not more than seven yards behind, I met another man going about the same pace. I was then about three quarters of a mile from the spot where Mr Whitehouse was found.

Cross examined by Mr Jervis: There are other roads by which the persons might have reached the place than that through the wood.

Ann Fox, the wife of Fox the publican was called and brought into the witness box; but being in ill-health, she immediately fainted away, and was not again called, it being understood on both sides that her testimony would not be material.

Thomas Taylor, examined by Mr Male.

“My father lives about 100 yards from Fox’s house; I live with him. I went out about a quarter after nine on the evening of the 3rd April to procure some mud for the oven. I heard a voice in the wood call “Fox! Fox!” not very loud, and then a noise as of something falling. It did not appear as if it were a heavy fall. I was about 300 or 400 yards from the place where Whitehouse was found. My father was not so near the spot as I, but he might have heard the fall. It certainly was not 10 o’clock. The road is hard where Whitehouse was found. I heard no footing of horses.”

John Taylor, the father of the last witness, stated that he heard the cry of “Fox” three times at half past 9 by his clock but heard no footing of horses.

Then there was the medical evidence given by the two Doctors Bloxham, of Halesowen.

Mr Stephen West Bloxham examined by Mr Hale:

“I am a surgeon in partnership with my father at Hales Owen. On the 4th April I was called to attend Mr Whitehouse, the deceased. I found him totally insensible and speechless. The left side was quite paralysed, and the right in constant action and convulsion. I found a wound a little above the projection at the back oof the head. It was about two inches in length and half an inch wide. On examining the wound with my finger, I found the scalp separated for two inches upward in that part which is naturally separated in infancy.

I will not swear that it might not be caused by a fall from a horse; but I think, from examination of the head after death, such consequences could not have been produced. I think a fall from a horse could not have occasioned so extensive an injury. The blow must have inclined upwards, because the scalp below was perfect and that above severed. I cannot swear that a kick from a horse would not have produced a wound and effects such as I described but I am not inclined to think it was done by a horse from other appearances of the head. There were two wounds full of dirt on the left temple which induced me to suppose that this temple came into contact with the ground. There was no dirt in the wound at the back of the head. Had the deceased fallen with his hat on, the consequences could not have been so extensive.

My opinion is that the wound and fractures in the skull were produced by a violent blow at the back of the head; I think from a flat instrument.  Any of the square sides of a gun barrel would be likely to produce the wound. I have no doubt that the blow behind was the cause of Mr Whitehouse’s death. I think he could know no one, and must have been incapable of shaking hands with any one from the time of the accident. I saw the prisoner about seven on the following morning in the presence of the deceased. I communicated to the prisoner, and so did my father, the dangerous state of Whitehouse. My father, in my hearing, expressed to the prisoner a wish to consult the family surgeon, and was informed by him that Mr Baddeley was the family surgeon. I do not recollect that he said anything further.”

Cross examined by Mr Pearson:

“I believe Mr Baddeley to be a very scientific man.

The two wounds on the temple might have been produced by a fall from the horse, and the back wound by a kick from the horse, without any other blow. The hat must have come off at the time when the chief blow was given. The back wound had bled some quantity, but I think not so much as to carry off the dirt. The edge of the horse-shoe might be free from dirt by constant friction. I should think the whole of the horse-shoe would not be received into the wound, but it would have admitted the edge of a horse-shoe. A kick from a horse would not be more violent than a blow from a man inflicted by a heavy instrument. A horse’s kick at the striking distance might produce the appearances at the back of the head; at least I will not swear it would not.

If the deceased answered a question as to his illness, I should think him sensible. If he grasped the hand of another in gratitude for fetching his friend and brother-in-law, this would be a proof he was sensible. I do not think it possible he could have moved from one side of the bed to the other, nor from a road into a ditch at six feet distance. Had a man given him the blow on the back of the head as he was riding, he must have fallen forwards, in which case his head would be towards the place to which he was proceeding.”

On re-examination, the witness said that if the horse had by a jerk turned round, the man might fall in a contrary direction. The wound appeared to be made with an instrument rather than a horse’s foot, because it was straight, not circular. It might possibly be given between the collar and the hat if the hat was on. The fracture was four or five inches towards the front of the head; which might have been produced by the weight and violence of the blow. Any square iron bar might have produced such a wound.

Mr C W Bloxam examined by Mr Puller:

“I am father of the last witness, and have been a surgeon 40 years. I saw the deceased the morning a after the violence but did not examine the wound itself until the morning after. I have heard the account given by my son, and as far as relates to the extent of the wounds, and the fracture of the skull, I entirely agree with him. After the death, I opened the wound and found it in the state which he has described. The impression on my mind at the time was, that it was inflicted by some heavy metallic substance, from the sharpness of the blow given. Such a derangement of the skull could not have been produced without a very wide instrument if of wood. The gun-barrel is certainly capable of producing the wound; I found part of the scalp which was mashed nearly to correspond with one of the squares of the barrel, but I cannot take it on myself to say that the wound actually was produced by it.

Cross-examined by Mr Russell:

“I could form very little judgment from the comparison with the scalp in the state it then was. Mr Baddeley did not attend when I made the examination, which was before the Coroner. It was possible the wound might have been given by great force. No injury was done to the hat.”

So the two doctors differed from Mr Fox as to whether Samuel Whitehouse was conscious at the Beech Tree Inn but seemed convinced that a blow from some metallic implement had caused the wound.

Then there was the evidence of Benjamin Granger, the person prosecuting this case:

Benjamin Granger, the prosecutor, constable of the parish of Halesowen, was examined by Mr Puller:

On the 13th of April, I went to examine the state of the wood. There are various little tracks which are very narrow; but one is waggon way, which is wider than the right path.

On the 20th I rode Mr Whitehouse’s mare, and she carried me safe. When I passed the second gate, I dropped the reins to see where she would take me, and she went straight up the right track. I ordered Fox to go through the same ceremony which he did in fetching the gun-barrel and returning and it took a minute. It is 576 yards from the second gate to the place where Mr Whitehouse was found. There is a bank at the place, on which a person standing might have struck Mr Whitehouse as he rode along. I was present before the coroner when Mr Downing was there. I heard his examination taken; he was told it was his option whether he would say anything. I heard it read to him, and saw him sign it.

As it appeared that the prisoner had been sworn at the start of the inquisition, Mr Justice Bayley thought the subsequent examination not admissible in evidence against him. His Counsel, however, waived the objection and it was read. It gave a narrative of the proceedings of the day, and stated that he never saw Whitehouse in the road, though expecting every moment to overtake him. The only part which could be supposed to assist the prosecutor’s case was, that in which he said he did not remember meeting with anyone; whereas Wakeman said that he met a man who he believed to be the prisoner.

This was the case for the prosecution.

The prisoner, being asked if he would say any thing for himself, replied “Nothing, my Lord, except that I am not guilty.”

Various witnesses were then called  for the defence:

Samuel Hodgets: “I live with my father, near the wood. I remember, a month before Mr Whitehouse’s death, his coming late at night to my father’s house, saying that he had been thrown from his mare and lost her. We went to look for her, and found that she had broken into one of the fields. He paid for the damage done to the stile she had injured, and rode her home.”

Thomas Binks: “I was servant to Mr Whitehouse, and live with his widow. About a month ago I was sent out on the mare; she plunged and threw me. I have attended the mare in the stable; she is kicking and vicious.”

Mr Thomas Winter, the surgeon who attended the last witness after his accident, stated that he was brought to his house stunned and with a cut on the ear. As the wound had no dirt in it, he thought it might probably be occasioned by a kick from the mare.

Joseph Cox, who lives in the road to the prisoner’s house from the place where the body was found, saw him pass at a quarter or twenty minutes before ten, at a slow pace, leading the colt with his right hand.

Mary Binks, the servant to theprisoner, remembered his arriving at home on the evening of the 3rd of April. He took the colt to the field, put up his horse, came in and shortly after went to bed.

Mr Baddeley, a surgeon in extensive practice at Dudley, was fetched by a brother of the deceased.He examined the wound. The whole injury seemed caused by one blow, which could not have been given without injuring the hat, if on. The effects might undoubtedly have been produced by the kick of a horse, and much more probably than by an instrument.

Mr Winter was called again, and said that having attended to the evidence, he had no doubt the wound might have been given by a kick of a horse. A horse’s foot would have given a more severe blow than a man could strike with a colt in his hand.

Mr Evans, surgeon at Shrewsbury, thought it much more probable that such an injury was caused by a kick from a horse than by human force.

Mr Thomas Whitehouse, a brother of the deceased, stated that he had often seen the deceased and the prisoner together, and always in apparent friendship.

What did the Judge say?

Mr Justice Bayley addressed the jury:

He had not stopped the case because when life was lost it was right that all the circumstances should be investigated with the greatest care. But now, if they thought every probability was in favour of the prisoner’s innocence – that the deceased might have been delayed on the road by taking the wrong path – that the position of the body at first, its subsequent removal after Downing had passed on, the direction in which the horse was found, and the whole demeanour of the prisoner, left them without doubt, it would be unnecessary for him to read over the evidence.

The Jury immediately said that they were satisfied and found a verdict of Not Guilty.

Mr Justice Bailey then said “I think it right, in the presence of the prisoner and of all who have heard the trial, to express my opinion that, if the unfortunate deceased did come to his death by human hands, which is by no means clear, it appears from all the evidence that it was from other hands than those of the prisoner.”

Downing, who during the trial had preserved an entire composure, burst into tears on hearing this address, and said with great emotion “Thank you greatly, my Lord; thank  you, Gentlemen of the Jury.” He was immediately discharged.”

So this was the account taken from newspapers at the time.

I hope my readers will forgive this very long account, but there are so many relevant details in the evidence that it seemed simplest to repeat the reports here.

So Joseph Downing was freed, without a stain on his character but that did not, apparently satisfy everyone. It appears that his family, at the time of the burial on 10th April, a week after the incident, were unsure what had happened and there is a note on the burial entry in the Register  “Murdered or found in a dying state being thrown from his horse and kicked.”

The case rumbled on. A Reward of £100, for the apprehension and conviction of the person or persons who robbed and murdered Samuel, was offered in a newspaper advertisement in Aris’s Birmingham Gazette on 15th April 1822. This report noted that he had been robbed of several bank notes, his watch, chain and seals and a leather shot pouch. A Coroner’s Inquest had been started and statements taken from Mr Downing and the Foxes, father and son and at that point the elder Fox had been detained in custody on suspicion of being implicated in the act. But it seems that nothing more came of that and attention then shifted to Joseph Downing.

Two years later

I found another article about a trial at Shewsbury Assizes in September 1824, two years later when a John Felton was charged, on the oath of the widow Mary Whitehouse with stealing Samuel Whitehouse’s silver watch, bank notes and other items. This was how the report began:

“ This case excited a very considerable interest, and the court was unusually crowded. To explain the circumstances of this transaction, it will be necessary to state the following facts:-

In the 3rd April 1822 Mr Samuel Whitehouse, a respectable farmer, residing at West Bromwich, went to visit a Mr Joseph Downing, an opulent farmer, residing in the Parish of Rowley, near the Beech Lanes, on the road to Halesowen, who was his brother-in-law” ……  etc, etc.

And then came the heavy hint that perhaps Mr Downing was not so innocent at all… an acquittal and the words of the Judge on that occasion did not prevent these innuendos, it seems.

“Mr Downing was apprehended on the charge of having murdered Mr Whitehouse and was fully committed for that crime and was tried at the Summer Assizes at Shrewsbury 1822 but was acquitted. It was sworn on that occasion, by a surgeon, that a blow had been inflicted with the barrel of a gun (and it was proved that Downing carried a gun when he left Fox’s house), which would have produced such an injury as that which occasioned the deceased’s death.

The prisoner Felton as also, at the time of the Coroner’s Inquest, in custody on suspicion of being concerned in the murder, and also a young man named Fox, the son of the man at whose house the deceased and Mr Joseph Downing were drinking on the night of the murder. They, however, were finally discharged.”

No mention, either of the opinion of another surgeon at the earlier trial that the injury was more likely to have been inflicted by a kick from a horse!

But back to the report on Felton’s trial:

“Mr Maule, for the prosecution, stated the case to the Jury. He said that the prisoner, at the time of the murder and robbery of Mr Whitehouse, kept the Pheasant public house, within half a mile of the spot where the deed was perpetrated. It could be proved that on the night in question, the prisoner [Felton] was seen on horseback, going in the direction where the body was found, and must have passed the place. It was not alleged that the prisoner inflicted the wounds that caused the death of the deceased, but that he passed by when the deceased lay insensible on the ground and rifled his person of his watch and ten £1 notes. The deceased, when first discovered, was lying on his face with his head towards a ditch, but in a quarter of an hour afterwards, when assistance was procured, on proceeding to the spot, he was found in a different position, and the pockets rifled of the watch and notes.

The deceased’s watch was found in the prisoner’s possession in June last, and in such a condition that no doubt could be entertained of its having been buried for a considerable period in the earth, as it was covered with soil and tarnished. On the prisoner being taken into custody, he told two different stories about his obtaining possession of the watch.

The Jury would seriously consider the facts he should prove, and if they were convinced of the prisoner’s guilt, they would discharge their duty by convicting him.”

Then entered a new character – Samuel Whitehouse’s widow.

Mrs Mary Whitehouse, the sister of Mr Joseph Downing, a good-looking woman, attired in deep mourning, was called. She was exceedingly agitated and could not speak for some time. She, being partially recovered, stated that, on the 3rd April, her husband went out shooting, and took with him the watch now produced.

Thomas Fox, the Landlord of the Pheasant public house, recollected the deceased, Paul Whitehouse and Joseph Downing coming to his house; the deceased had bank notes in his pocket and a silver watch. [Two errors here – it was Samuel, not Paul Whitehouse who died. At the time of the original incident, Thomas Fox was not the landlord of the Pheasant, the accused John Felton was!]

Richard Aston, whose detailed evidence in Downing’s trial we saw earlier in this script, found the deceased in the road insensible, and went to the Beech tree public-house for assistance; on returning to the deceased, he said “I heard a halloo, and then a second halloo; and I made a hallooing in answer, and directly after I heard a horse gallop off in a direction towards the Pheasant public house, which is about half a mile from where the deceased lay. When I arrived where the deceased was lying, I found he had been removed into the ditch; his waistcoat was raised up; the waistband of his breeches was unbuttoned, and one of the pockets was unbuttoned. I did not see that he had a watch when I first saw him. He had no watch when I saw him again. I assisted in removing him to the Beech Tree, where he lived two days in a state of insensibility.”

John Downing – [yes, almost certainly distantly related to the Rowley Downings!]: “I live at Harborne; on the night of the 3rd April 1822 about twenty minutes past nine, I saw the prisoner at the bar pass my house on horseback, which is situate about half a mile from where Mr Whitehouse was found, and in the direct road to the Pheasant public –house. The prisoner’s father lived at Harborne; I particularly noticed the prisoner by his beating his horse over the shoulders to make him go faster. It was a moon-light night; I am sure it was the prisoner.”

Cross-examined by Mr Maule:

“I saw the prisoner on other days in April frequently; he visited his father, and my house is on the road, between the residence of father and son; the prisoner might have gone up a turnpike road after he passed my house and not have passed through the wood.”

Questioned by the Judge:

“I was 20 yards off the prisoner when he passed me; it is not uncommon for a man to beat a horse on the shoulder; I did not speak to the prisoner, though he was a neighbour; his horse was darkish; I have known the prisoner since he was a child.”

Moses Hyam identified the watch left in Mrs Tonk’s possession to be the same he sold to Whitehouse.

Edmund Darby, a constable, apprehended the prisoner at Birmingham, when he gave different accounts how he obtained it.

The prisoner declined saying anything in his defence, and called several witnesses, who gave him a good character.

Mr Justice Park considered that the circumstances were very slight against the prisoner.

The Jury returned a verdict of Not Guilty.

More details about the strange circumstances surrounding the watch emerged in a report in the Shrewsbury Chronicle dated 20 August 1824:

John Felton, charged with stealing a silver watch, value £3, from Samuel Whitehouse.

Elizabeth Tonks, took the Pheasant Inn off the prisoner’s hands in June 1822. In October last, he brought a dirty and tarnished silver watch to her house; he asked if a man had been there to enquire for him, and on being answered in the negative, he told Mrs Tonks that he had advanced 11/- (eleven shillings) on the watch to a strange man who was to have met him there to redeem it; he then asked Mrs Tonks to let him have 11/- on it, but enjoined her to let no one know of the transaction, and particularly not her servant girl, who had lived with him also at the Pheasant, when he kept it; witness accordingly took the watch in pledge, cleaned it in the best way she could, and used it; and that afterwards, when the matter became public, she gave it up to Darby, the constable.

Darby stated that he apprehended the prisoner at Bromsgrove Fair, where he had horses to sell, and telling him he was come to apprehend him, he said “Are you, by God! About that damned watch; I do not care about it; I had it of a man whom I did not know.”

A great number of respectable persons who had known the prisoner from 4 to 26 years, gave him a most excellent character.

The names of certain people seem to recur in these trials and it is likely that the local authorities were under some pressure to solve this mystery, and numerous people seem to have come under suspicion.

Summary

Was Joseph involved in attacking his brother-in-law? He certainly had nothing to gain financially – Joseph was a very wealthy man, as was Mary Downing, Samuel’s wife and both Joseph and Mary had received substantial bequests from their uncle Isaac Downing in 1814. And there is no evidence that the men were on bad terms, quite the contrary. So what motive could he have had? It’s difficult to think what motive Tom Fox would have had either, although he too clearly came under suspicion.

My own view is that it seems perfectly possible to me that, with Samuel riding in the dark in a very drunken state, his unreliable horse could have thrown him as he rode through the wood and then kicked him in the head and the horse was certainly running wild at that time. It appears that the Judge at the trial also had great doubt about whether Samuel had died as a result of a human attack.

The route taken by the two men – both of whom were the worse for alcohol – would have diverged anyway at some point cross country and it was clear that there were various tracks and pathways through the Lightwoods and that Joseph Downing had got lost there before. And could he really have attacked his brother-in-law so viciously while he was himself on a horse and leading a colt with his right hand? It seems unlikely.

That Samuel was subsequently robbed definitely happened, perhaps by one or more passing men who took advantage of his unconscious state and may not even have realised that he was so badly injured, (it seems the wound was on the back of  his head and not immediately obvious in the dark of the woods). And he probably smelled of drink, too so the thief may just have thought he had fallen down drunk.

But what a fascinating glimpse of the life these men led and how the movements of people along the road were noted by the local residents!

I wonder whether Joseph was able to resume anything like his normal life after that. Was there always a whisper of doubt about his innocence? Did his wife Nancy suspect that he might have killed her brother? Did his sister Mary think that he had struck down her husband? Did all five of his daughters choose to live with their Aunt Mary, Samuel’s widow, in West Bromwich because of family issues or did they just prefer to live in a town? Who knows? They all returned to Turner’s Hill, to live with their mother and brother Isaac after their father’s death.  I am currently trying to track down Joseph’s Will and also his son Isaac’s Will which may give some clues. Did all of those daughters and Isaac remain unmarried because of the family disgrace? We shall never know.

Would there have been much sympathy in Rowley in 1822 for Joseph? Remember that only the year before, four Rowley men had been sentenced to death for a minor robbery at the home of Joseph’s father, although those sentences were commuted to transportation, so local support might have been thin on the ground.

So, there it is – a real life murder mystery, unsolved, it seems, to this day. Or was it a terrible mishap, involving a man worse for drink, a bad tempered horse and an opportunistic thief?

What do you think?

The 1841 Census – Turner’s Hill 3 Redferns but mainly Downings

The next family on the 1841 Census were the Redferns, Joseph Redfern, his wife Ann Maria (nee Priest) and their elder children. This is how the family were shown in that Census:

Christian nameSurnameAgeOccupationWhether born in CountyWhether born in Scotland, Ireland or Foreign Parts
JosephRedfern35LabourerYes 
MariaRedfern40 Yes 
SarahRedfern12 Yes 
ElizaRedfern10 Yes 
JosephRedfern8 Yes 
WilliamRedfern6 Yes 
AnnRedfern4 Yes 
ThomasPriest15 Yes 

Thomas Priest was Joseph’s stepson, the illegitimate son of Ann Maria Priest.

No need for much new research on this family, I did a family study on this family in August and September 2023 which appears in two posts.

There is little new to be added to that information since then so any  interested readers may wish to refresh their memories from those posts:

The Downing Family

Next along the hill were Joseph Downing and his family, Joseph was shown as a farmer. This was their household:

Christian nameSurnameAgeOccupationWhether born in CountyWhether born in Scotland, Ireland or Foreign Parts
JosephDowning55FarmerYes 
Nancy 50 Yes 
Isaac 25 Yes 
SarahWard20Female ServantNo 
HannahHarris30 No 

The Downing Family

There are many Downings in and around the Rowley area, also in Tividale, Sedgley, West Bromwich and Harborne and many of them were owners or tenants of land and therefore more prosperous than most of the average nailers. They intermarried with other families of similar status in the area. Many of them left Wills which, where I have been able to find them, have been the source of a lot of information.

Joseph Downing (1784-1849)

Joseph’s age in the 1841 Census indicates a birth year of about 1786, bearing in mind that in this census adult ages were rounded down to the nearest five years. I had hoped that I would be able to find Joseph in the 1851 Census which would give me a more accurate year but although I found Nancy still on Turner’s Hill with various others, she was now a widow. So now I knew that Joseph had died between 1841 and 1851, into the period of civil registration so easier to find – this should give me an age from the death registration and from the burial if I was able to find that. There were several death registrations of Joseph Downings in the Dudley Registration District between those dates but only one of them was for a Joseph of the right age. Joseph Downing, aged 65, died in the first quarter of 1849 which brings me back to a birth date of about 1784. And this Joseph Downing, aged 65, and – according to the entry in the Burial Register – of Turner’s Hill was buried at St Giles on 2 January 1849. So this is definitely the right Joseph Downing. The Burial entry indicates that he died of a diseased heart.

So now I could look for a baptism of this Joseph. I searched FreeREG for a period from 1780 to 1790 in Rowley Regis and the surrounding area within 7.5 miles. Somewhat to my surprise, there were only two such baptisms – one in 1780 in Himley – a little early if our Joseph’s age was recorded correctly and quite a long way away  – and one in Rowley Regis on 11 January 1784. It seems likely that this second Joseph was our man. This Joseph was the son of Paul and Ann Downing, who had also had a daughter Mary baptised at St Giles in 1782. There were no other baptisms for this couple anywhere that I could find which makes me suspect that the Hannah Downing who died in July 1786 and was buried at St Giles may have been this Ann – Ann and Hannah are sometimes used interchangeably. Or it is possible that she was the Ann Downing who was buried at Halesowen in December 1792. The only other trace that I could find at that point of Paul Downing was a burial at St Giles in November 1823, aged 81 (giving a birth year of about 1742) and giving his abode as Turner’s Hill. So, again, that ties in neatly with this family.

Joseph’s father Paul Downing (1742-1823)

Paul is not a common name in the Downing family nor indeed in Rowley Regis at this time, as far as I can see, but I was able to find a marriage of a Paul Downing on 14 February 1782 to Ann Darby – another name associated with Rowley – by Licence (which indicates a certain level of wealth or social standing). The marriage is listed as having taken place at Rowley Regis cum Clent but I cannot see it in the Rowley Regis Register so presumably it took place at Clent.  And there was a Paul Downing baptised at Harborne on 10 February 1765 who may have been connected in some way, he was the son of John and Martha Downing. The only Paul Downing that I have been able to find in the area in the 1841 Census was a blacksmith living in Hagley Road, Harborne so it does seem that the Downings in that area used Paul as a Christian name, more so than the Rowley Downings. However, I  know from other sources (of which more anon) that this Joseph Downing was the nephew of Isaac Downing of Turner’s Hill.

There was a Paul Downing living on Turner’s Hill from at least about 1782 until 1823. I found a newspaper report that in 1821, John Fox, John Priest, Samuel Perry, Benjamin Perry and Ephraim Rollason of Rowley were convicted at Stafford Assizes for housebreaking at the dwelling-house of Paul Downing in April 1821 and stealing a coat, two sheets and other goods. This does make me think that Paul Downing must have been living in a house of a larger than average size for the village. It would not have taken four men to burgle the average small cottage in the village.

For this crime all four were sentenced to death at Stafford Assizes, which seems a harsh sentence to our modern thinking although I have been able to discover that these death sentneces were commuted and they were all were transported to Australia instead. This was in the period of demobilisation of the army after Waterloo, leading to mass unemployment, poor harvests owing to bad weather, the Peterloo Massacre in 1819 and the introduction of the Corn laws which had a disastrous impact on the poor. Who knows what motivated these four men to break in and steal, though it does not appear that they managed to steal very much and the death sentences seem draconian to us today. I had also noted that Ephraim Rollason appeared in court a couple of times previously charged with stealing so this may not have been a one-off. I cannot help thinking that it would not have made the Downing family very popular amongst the poorer families of the hamlets who lost four of their men.

There was also Isaac Downing on Turner’s Hill at this time, he was buried at St Giles in November 1814, of Turner’s Hill, aged 75, having died of asthma. It seems that Paul and Isaac were brothers. And the maps which appear to have been prepared in connection with the Enclosures in Rowley in the late 1790s or very early 1800s, also show Paul Downing as tenant of land on Turner’s Hill. Looking back, I see that I wrote at some length about the Downings (amongst other families) in my piece about the farms in the Lost Hamlets.

Joseph and Nancy

Joseph Downing married Nancy Whitehouse – again by Licence – at St Giles, on 29 March 1810, the witnesses to this marriage were Mary Downing and William Whitehouse, a really Rowley union, it seems!  A daughter Emma was baptised at Rowley on 17 September 1810, daughter of Joseph and Nancy, followed by Matilda in 1813, Isaac in 1815, Mary Ann in 1818, Lavinia (1821-1824), Amelia in 1823 and another Lavinia – Lavinia Augusta in 1829. In all of these baptisms except the first, Joseph was described as a ‘Beast Leech’.

The ‘beast leech’

A ‘beast leech’ is an old term for a man practiced in healing cattle, which would have included horses and other livestock  – a veterinary or cow doctor. The term is first recorded, according to the Oxford English Dictionary, in 1627 in a dictionary by F Holyoake and that dictionary thinks that it was a term used in English Regional dialect. Certainly there are numerous examples of this term in Yorkshire in the mid 1700s but clearly it was not limited to there. 

In archaic and Old English the word leech meant a physician, healer or surgeon and the term apparently comes from the Old English word lǣce which meant healer. This use had apparently fallen mostly out of use by the 17th century. But, as we can see, the use certainly continued in connection with animals.

And it must have been that there was a need for people experienced and knowledgeable in the treatment of sick animals in most farming communities. Doubtless some horse dealers, grooms, cattle dealers developed their own expertise in dealing with ailments and problems in their own specialisms but the description of Joseph as a beast leech over a period of years suggests that he was recognised as having particular skills in this area and earning his living from his practice and, since his uncle was also a beast leech, this may have been a family occupation.  There is certainly continuing evidence that the Downing family were particularly interested in cattle breeding.  But by 1841 Joseph was described simply as a farmer in the census.

So this was the only Census in which Joseph Downing appeared, and he died, aged 65, on the 27th December 1848 and was buried at St Giles on 2 January 1849. There is much more to say about Joseph Downing, so much that this will be a separate  post about him, soon!

Nancy Downing (nee Whitehouse) 1788-1855

Nancy Whitehouse was born in about 1788-79, which fits with both the age shown in the 1841 and from the age of 62 which she gave in the 1851 Census.  There were four Nancy Whitehouses baptised between 1785 and 1790 in the immediate area of Rowley, two in Wednesbury and one in Kingswinford. But the fourth one was baptised in Rowley Regis on 11 May 1788 which is a close fit, she was the daughter of William and Hannah Whitehouse. As Nancy gives her place of birth in the census as Rowley it seems likely that this is our Nancy.

In 1851, as a widow, Nancy was still living on Turner’s Hill. With her then were her surviving children Isaac (35), Mary (30), Amelia (27), Lavinia (21), along with a Thomas Whitehouse, aged 63, a widower shown as a ‘resident’ (not shown as a relative) and two servants – Joseph Hodgets who was a manservant, aged 20 and Caroline Wasnidge, a general servant aged 35. All of these were born in Rowley Regis except Thomas who was marked born in Staffordshire and Caroline who was born in Birmingham.

As I have often noted previously, those prosperous enough to employ servants often employed people from outside the village.

In 1851, all of the children listed were unmarried. Nancy‘s occupation was listed as an annuitant, as were her three daughters while her son Isaac was shown as a ‘proprietor of lands, etc’, as was Thomas Whitehouse. No mention of farming at all. So this was definitely a well-to-do family on both sides, it seems, owning land and wealthy enough to leave annuities for their unmarried daughters.

Where were the Downing daughters in 1841?

I was curious as to where the four girls, then 20, 17, 15 and 11 were in 1841 as they were not with their parents. The answer was that they, were with Thomas Whitehouse and a Mary Whitehouse, (b.1786, possibly his wife or his sister-in-law)at his home in High Street, West Bromwich. It seems very likely that Thomas was related to them in some way.

This Thomas Whitehouse was a Currier, these were skilled craftsmen, currying was the process of stretching and finishing tanned leather, using techniques of dressing, finishing and colouring to give the leather the desired colour. The leather was then ready to pass on to the finishing trades such as saddlery, bridlery, shoemaking or glovemaking. Walsall was at that time the capital of saddlery in England, plus the making of bridles and harnesses and leather goods, due to the proximity of lime pits used for tanning leather and metal industries supplying metal fittings so Thomas Whitehouse would have had a ready market nearby.

Whilst looking at the Whitehouse family, of whom there were many in this area, I noticed a list published in the Worcester Journal in 1845, of ‘members of the Dudley and West Bromwich Bank” which also showed their occupations and where they lived. There were seven Whitehouses listed among the investors: Richard from Oakham who was a Cattle Dealer (a source for Thomas’s hides, perhaps?); a Joseph and a John, both of Dudley and both canal carriers; a William and a William Frederick of West Bromwich, both Nail Merchants; Thomas of West Bromwich, a currier plus the representatives of a Samuel Whitehouse Deceased, also of West Bromwich and also a currier; and a William of Dudley and West Bromwich who was a Canal Carrier. There were no Downings listed among the Investors, perhaps merchants had more disposable capital than farmers, or perhaps they were more inclined to invest in banks. This is quite a close cluster of Whitehouses, who seemed – at least some of the time  – to be close to each other in location and to be occupied in complimentary businesses. It is quite possible they were all related.

William and Hannah Whitehouse’s family

I looked to see what other children William and Hannah Whitehouse had had baptised at Rowley Regis around the time of Nancy’s birth. The first was Joseph in January 1775 which makes me think that William Whitehouse and Hannah Willetts were the couple who were married at St Philip’s, Birmingham on 14 February 1774. Then followed Samuel in 1777, William in 1780, Thomas in 1785, and Nancy in 1788. However, of these, I have discovered, from the Will of William Whitehouse (abt 1751-1827), Nancy’s father, that his son William died in 1812, sons Samuel and Thomas both died in 1822, leaving only his eldest son Joseph and Nancy herself of his children. So whoever the Thomas Whitehouse shown in the 1841 Census was , he was not Nancy’s brother, though he was very likely related.

So the Thomas and Samuel Whitehouse who were both curriers in West Bromwich must have been brothers from another or at least more distant twig of the Whitehouse family.

But it was when I was looking at these Whitehouse men that I came across a fascinating story of which more in my next post. But what I discovered for certain was that Samuel and Nancy and Thomas Whitehouse –were definitely siblings and that Joseph Downing had married Nancy Whitehouse in 1810 and Samuel Whitehouse had married Mary Downing in 1813 – Joseph’s sister and only sibling. So the families were double in-laws and clearly very closely connected!  

Nancy Downing died in 1855 and was buried at St Giles on 22 August that year, her age given as 67 and her abode as Turner’s Hill. The person making the burial entry noted that the cause of death was General Decay. Thomas Whitehouse, appears to have died in May 1852 in Rowley Regis and was buried in West Bromwich, which had previously been his business base and home for many years.

Isaac Downing (1815-1874)

Isaac was still living on Turner’s Hill in 1851, listed within his mother’s household and described as a “Proprietor of Lands, etc.” His sisters Mary, Amelia and Lavinia were also living there by that time and Thomas Whitehouse.

In 1861 Isaac was still there – although it is clear from the Census that the family were not living at Turner’s Hill Farm, as this is shown separately and occupied by a different family. The Downing abode was a private house. By this time, his mother and Thomas Whitehouse had died and Isaac, by then 42 and unmarried, was shown as the Head of the Household and described as “Principal Occupation: General Superintendence of the cultivation of Land”. Again his three sisters were also living there, all single.

By 1871, Isaac was 55 and shown as a Landowner and Farmer, employing 4 men. His sisters Mary and Lavinia were still with him, all of them unmarried.

Isaac died in 1874, aged 59 and was buried at St Giles on 20 November 1874. He was the last surviving issue of Joseph and Nancy.

Joseph and Nancy’s daughters

From another source, I learned that Mr and Mrs Samuel Whitehouse had been married six or seven years, and had no children of their own. Joseph Downing, who had married Samuel Whitehouse’s sister had four or five children. Samuel Whitehouse had reportedly taken Joseph and Nancy’s eldest daughter Emma from her birth and had adopted her as his own. He had also sent two other of Downing’s children to school, Whitehouse expressing his great satisfaction at what he had done, and saying what good children they were.

Samuel Whitehouse and his brother Thomas both died in 1822 when Emma was about 12 but I suspect that at least one of the girls, if not all, remained with his widow Mary nee Downing. Another Thomas Whitehouse, a bachelor, married a Mary Whitehouse, a widow, by Licence in West Bromwich on 27 September 1827 and I suspect that this is the Thomas and Mary Whitehouse with whom the girls were living in 1841. 

Just to add to the confusion about this family, when this second Thomas died in 1852, in his will he referred to his ‘late brother Samuel’ – don’t you just love it when branches of families use all the same Christian names…?  And in the same Will, the second Thomas left property to a William and Joseph Whitehouse of Rowley, some minor bequests and the residue of his estate to the Downing children, naming Isaac as his nephew. Isaac was Mary’s nephew – but not his but it appears he considered Isaac as such.

Of Joseph and Nancy’s children then, their second daughter Matilda (1813-1837) had died of fever on 24th October 1837, aged 24 and of The Heath, West Bromwich (which was where Samuel and Mary Whitehouse were living at the time of his death and presumably where she continued to live) and was buried at West Bromwich. Emma (1810-1850) had died of Typhus Fever at Great Malvern, unmarried, aged 40 in 1850 and was also buried at West Bromwich. Amelia (1824-1861) died in 1861 and was buried at St Giles  on 22 July. Lavinia Augusta (1829-1873) died on 12 March 1873 of Heart disease and was buried at St Giles on 18 March; her sister Mary Ann (1818-1873) died ten days later on 22 March 1873 of Hepatitis and Fatty degeneration of the heart and was buried at St Giles on 27 March. Isaac was described in their Probate Records as ‘Brother and only Next of Kin’. Isaac died the following year on 15th November, with Angina Pectoris given as the cause of death.  None of the children married.

So, this particular family ended in 1874. What a contrast with some of the other, poorer families in the area who left dozens of grandchildren and great-grandchildren. I have not yet managed to find all of the Wills for this branch of the family and suspect they may be at Stafford Record Office but will continue to try to trace them for the further information they contain.

What sort of social life did the family lead?

I wondered what sort of life Isaac lived, whether the unmarried siblings were reclusive or whether they took part in life in the village.

What was Turner’s Hill House like?

I found an advertisement in the County Advertiser in 1875 which was placed by the Trustees of the Will of this Isaac Downing. This refers principally to the site as a

“Freehold Mineral Property , comprising a desirable Residence and Premises and several closes of very rich Pasture Land adjoining, with an extensive bed of Rowley Rag stone therein, together with the very valuable MINES and MINERALS thereunder ,situate at Turner’s Hill”.

This was being sold at Dudley in One lot and there was some further description of the house itself.

“That very desirable and compact FREEHOLD ESTATE, called TURNER’S HILL, with residence, pleasure grounds, luxuriant Shrubberies, Greenhouses, Vineries, Stables, Coach-Houses, Outbuildings, Entrance Lodge and Premises occupied therewith, and  several closes of very fertile Pasture Land, with the Outbuildings and Cottages adjoining, the whole lying well together and comprising an area of nearly 20 acres.”

This surprised me, I had not realised how extensive the estate was. I wonder where the Entrance Lodge was? On Turner’s Hill or somewhere off Portway? So I looked on the NLS webpage and found this image of the top of Turner’s Hill which shows Turner’s Hill Farm quite clearly. And I now think that the estate called Cloudlands on this map is Turner’s Hill House – it fits the description above very well, it has shrubberies and gardens, it has outbuildings and cottages, it has an entrance lodge!  

Copyright: National Library of Scotland Creative Commons Re-use.

Another paragraph notes “This property is situated in the very centre of the South Staffordshire Coalfield, and the Earl of Dudley’s new sinkings at Lye Cross are only a few yards from it’s boundary, proving beyond doubt the existence of Thick Coal of the very best quality under the entire Estate.”

The earlier Isaac Downing probably lived here, too and the previous news snippet shows that he had an estate worth £1,000 a year, so presumably this was that estate. The 1800 Enclosure Map shows Isaac Downing and Paul Downing as tenants in this area. And was this the house that attracted the attention of four burglars?  In another context, in 1822, I noted Joseph Downing was described as a “opulent farmer”. So it appears that the family were quite wealthy.

Copyright: Mike Fenton.

Comparing this photograph with the map and the position of the road up between the quarries, I think that the large white house in the middle of the picture is probably Turner’s Hill House, much nearer to the edge of the quarry when this picture was taken than when the map was surveyed in the 1890s.

So the family lived in some luxury and they owned most of the surrounding cottages. I was surprised that there is very little evidence of live-in servants, in the census entries there is usually only one or at most two servants, I would have expected coachmen, grooms or gardeners, with the buildings and gardens listed.

From the description in the advertisement, I now think that all of this little group of cottages was associated with Turner’s Hill House and the farm – and quite possibly most of the people living in the houses worked for the Downings in one way or another. Perhaps Mary Cooper the washerwoman or Hannah Cooper or Phoebe Brinton living a few yards down the lane, actually worked for the Downings? I had wondered why a washerwoman would live so far from the village so that she or her customers would have to carry laundry a long way. But if she worked in a laundry at Turner’s Hill House, that would make more sense. So, in effect, this seems to have been another self-contained enclave in a similar way to Gadd’s Green, but associated – at least in the mid to late 1800s with the Turner’s Hill House estate, and the Downing family. This makes sense in many ways since the hamlet was so physically removed from neighbouring hamlets by a steep hill.

Isaac’s social standing

There is not much to be found about the Downing daughters and their lives. But their brother was easier to track. I noticed that in 1851, Isaac was one of several gentlemen appointed as assignees to hold finds in a bankruptcy case of a local Bank which implies a certain respectability and good standing in the financial community.  In 1855, Isaac was shown as one of the Churchwardens which implies at least some association with St Giles’s, the Parish Church. In 1856 Isaac was listed as holding a General Game Certificate and certainly his father Joseph and his uncle Samuel went shooting regularly. In 1867, Isaac Downing, of Turner’s Hill was elected as a member of the Royal Agricultural Society which indicates a continuing interest in farming then.

In the 1851 and the 1871 censuses the family had visitors staying who were named Crump and it seems that these were the children of the then Vicar William Crump so clearly the family had some social contacts within the village.

The Cattle Connection

You may remember, when I listed Whitehouses in business, earlier in this piece, I mentioned a  Richard Whitehouse from Oakham who was a Cattle Dealer. This must have been very close to the Downing estate and it is more than possible that Richard was related to Nancy, Joseph Downing’s wife.

The Sale of the Shorthorn Cattle Herd

I wonder whether this was a particular Downing interest, as in 1872, shortly before Isaac Downing died, there were numerous reports including one in the Gloucester Journal that he and another man Mr John Harwood of Winterfold, Kidderminster, sold their

“entire herds of shorthorn cattle, consisting of about 65 Head of Bulls, Cows and Heifers, of the Oxford, Waterloo, Wild Eyes, Kirklevington, Lally, Blanche and Surmise Tribes. More than half the Stock are directly descended from animals bred at Kirklevington, and the others largely inherit this highly fashionable blood. The sale includes the magnificent Bull Third Duke of Claro (23729), whose Sire and Dam were both by the celebrated Seventh Duke of York (17754(), and the superb Bull Eighth Duke of Geneva (28390). The young stock are by these excellent Sires, and the Cows and Heifers are served by them. Catalogues, with pedigrees may be had on application to Mr Strafford of Euston Square, London or of Mr Minett, at Winterfold.” Clearly this was no small local sale and generated considerable interest and the animals sold for what were described as “extraordinary prices” .

Another report in that Journal  a little later describes the sale itself. The sale was held

“in one of the large parks connected with the residence of Mr John Harward at Winterfold, situated about three miles from Kidderminster.  There was a large attendance of Shorthorn Breeders from all parts of the country. Among those present were the Lord Fitzhardinge, the Earl of Bective, Colonel Kingscote, MO, the agents of Lord Skelmoersdale, Mr Brogden MP, Colonel Morris (New York), the agent of the Duke of Devonshire, the agent of Sir W Throckmorton, etc.

Luncheon was served, prior to the sale, to which about 500 sat down. Five hundred! That must have been quite a sight to see! This picture shows Winterfold House in 1850 so it was a very grand establishment.

Copyright: Historic England.

At the sale, one animal, named as the Fifth Maid of Oxford, was sold to Mr G Moore of Whitehall, Cumberland for 900 guineas. Lot 26 was sold to a Mr Bowley of Cirencester for £210 guineas and was said to be one of the purest and best bred animals of that tribe in the Kingdom. In the eight-bull department – Lord Fitzhardinge  (Of the Berkeley Castle estate near where I live now) had started the bidding for the Duke of Geneva, at £900 guineas but it was eventually  purchased by Mr Leney of Kent, for the sum of £1,650 guineas,  said to be a “remarkable fine animal, fully developed in every particular, healthy in appearance and well fed.”

The sums raised by the sale were: Cows £15,458; heifers £12,343; and the bulls £3,114. The average price per head was £253/16s. the highest on record.

So if Isaac was closely involved with the breeding of this herd, he was clearly a serious breeder. John Harward was also named as one of the executors of Isaac’s Will so they were at least good friends although I have found no evidence that they were related.

John Harward was a solicitor and apparently a temperance campaigner and preacher. He only outlived Isaac by a few years but I noted that there was another very large sale of Harward’s cattle in 1880 and almost continuous reports of sales of individual beasts after Isaac’s death so clearly Harward had not sold his entire herd at the sale detailed above, perhaps only ones jointly owned with Isaac Downing. I have also learned from the National Archives catalogue that a cache of legal documents relating to the “Downing/Whitehouse/Crump family” was deposited at Stafford Record Office by Harward and Evers, Solicitors of Stourbridge, John’s company, so I am considering whether a visit to Stafford Archives might be worthwhile at some point.

Summary

Generally building the pictures of the lives of this family was slow because they were not very well documented anywhere, as other families often are on Ancestry or Find My Past. Perhaps this is because there were no descendants, so there was less reason for family historians now to document them so fully.

But it appears that Isaac, at least, was not completely reclusive and played a part in society and was, clearly, extremely wealthy in comparison with most residents of the village. It seems rather sad that this wealth and privilege did not prevent all the children of Joseph and Nancy remaining single and dying at relatively early ages and without leaving children to continue their legacy.

One more post to come on the residents of Turner’s Hill in 1841 and another on a particular episode the Downing/Whitehouse families!